shapinglight: (Lucifer)
[personal profile] shapinglight
Okay, in pursuit of keeping things light(ish) on this journal, have another post about Lucifer.

Spoilers behind cut for both the TV show and the comics. In other words, more meandering about how they're the same (not very much) and how they differ.



So Lucifer has gone on hiatus till May. As previously stated in this context, aaargh! That's ages! I do hope such a long break won't affect its chances of renewal, which were looking pretty positive as of when it went off air.

Anyway, how to fill the gulf of time until it returns (or rather, how to fill that part of the gulf of time that needs to relax with not-to-be-taken-that-seriously TV shows). Well, obviously, a complete re-watch is in order, and I have in fact started that - my second re-watch, actually, since I did the same thing when it went on hiatus in November (yes, I'm a fan, can you tell?). I'm finding myself laughing out loud quite a lot this time - certainly more than I did the first time, though I always found the show humorous -which goes to show I really am in that happy place you go to when you first join a fandom and everything about the source material seems wonderful, and if anyone critiques it, you feel a little cross on its behalf - especially if you know the critiquer is not 'a fan like you' and therefore 'doesn't get it.'

Further to that, I've now watched two episodes. The second is the one where Lucifer and Chloe cross paths with a scuzzy paparazzo, who feels so guilty about the things he's done in his life, he's prepared to take the fall for his protege, who is doing even worse things. Remember that? Anyway, towards the end of the episode, Lucifer and Maze set up a punishment scenario, where they invite the paparazzo and his erstwhile protege - AKA murderous little scumbag - to take potshots at each other. Before they do, Lucifer 'apologises' to them for the fact that, if they go to hell, there's no one to sort out their punishments there, and I found myself thinking, 'Ah-hah! That statement was totally contradicted by what happened in the latest episode (season 2 ep 13, for anyone who cares), in which hell seemed to be carrying on quite happily without Lucifer's presence.

Maybe someone else is in charge, I thought, or maybe it's just a case of the show writers forgetting, or retconning, what they'd previously made canon? And that's when I thought, 'Aww, how terribly Jossian,' and instantly forgave them.

I really am far gone, aren't I?

Other thoughts in brief:

All seven of the main characters (Lucifer, Chloe, Amenadiel, Maze, Dan, Dr Linda, Trixie) are fully formed and fleshed out from the very first episode. I found that quite impressive, though it probably happens in most shows and I've forgotten. Tom Ellis, in particular, is really, really good.

Lucifer used to wear a leather jacket quite often in the early season 1 episodes, but he's stopped. I forget whether he says why. Will have to listen out and see.

Then there's the comics - or, to be specific, the new Lucifer comics series by Holly Black and Lee Garbett, (which I've only read the first graphic novel of, so please don't spoiler me for anything later) which features many of the surviving characters from the original series by Mike Carey, with the addition of Lucifer's brother Gabriel, who I understand has featured in Hellblazer, but who (I think) is only seen once in the original Lucifer series. Gabriel has, at some point, lost his wings and been thrown out of heaven (also known as the Silver City). He also has a gaping hole in his chest where his heart has been ripped out by a succubus that John Constantine tricked him into having sex with - and it's that, in fact, that caused him to be thrown out of heaven in the first place.

Seems to me that the story of Gabriel from the comics is being conflated somewhat with Amenadiel in the show, here. Amenadiel believes that the loss of his angelic powers, including his wings, is down to various sins he's committed since coming to earth, including having sex with a demon.

Either that, or the show writers were thinking about Preacher with the Amenadiel/Maze hook-up (which I'll think even more if Maze does end up pregnant), or are ripping off Supernatural, which I know very little about, except what I've read on various fan wikis. But even if they have done it a little bit with the character of Lucifer's mother (there isn't one all-powerful celestial being, there are two, male and female, like in Supernatural, which is not the case in the comics) I don't think they need to go there again, actually, and I hope they won't. There's enough source material from the Lucifer comics, including a huge amount of dysfunctional family stuff they can do with Lucifer and his brother and sister angels.

And it probably goes two ways anyway. The Lucifer comics series pre-dates the later seasons of Supernatural. Pop culture will eat itself, etc, etc.

Date: 2017-02-08 05:24 pm (UTC)
yourlibrarian: SamDeanChurchSteps-misty_creates (SPN-SamDeanChurchSteps-misty_creates)
From: [personal profile] yourlibrarian
'Ah-hah! That statement was totally contradicted by what happened in the latest episode (season 2 ep 13, for anyone who cares), in which hell seemed to be carrying on quite happily without Lucifer's presence.

Maybe someone else is in charge, I thought, or maybe it's just a case of the show writers forgetting, or retconning, what they'd previously made canon?


I was thinking the same thing, not specifically with that episode in mind but, supposedly Lucifer's absence (and presumably Maze's as well) was causing all sorts of chaos and it contributed to Mom being able to escape. So I expected a different problem greeting him than having to face his own guilt.

I do think it was something ignored not only because it suited the needs of their current arc but also because the arc of S1 was "return Lucifer to hell." That's been pretty much abandoned with the current storyline which is more about "return all the celestial beings to heaven." And someone always fills a power vacuum so I do think it likely someone else is in charge and this may come into play down the line.

I can say that I don't see a lot of crossover with Supernatural in terms of the fallen angel issue although there is overlap in the larger plot with angel factions developing and wanting to return to heaven or being locked out, and everyone blaming God for various things. I do not doubt though that the comics influenced all that since Castiel may have been a different character than Constantine but was clearly modeled after him in appearance.

Speaking of Preacher, have you watched that series and what did you think?
Edited Date: 2017-02-08 05:25 pm (UTC)

Date: 2017-02-10 03:45 pm (UTC)
yourlibrarian: Angel and Lindsey (BUF-ChosenTwo-callingpiper)
From: [personal profile] yourlibrarian
I didn't watch it either because the commercials for it gave me that impression, though I read elsewhere that the series was good. So I may not take it up.

I think very few in Hollywood pay attention to SPN so I doubt it influenced Lucifer directly. The whole procedural set-up seems much more Castle to me and I think is more directly connected to the failed Forever in crossing over a supernatural angle with a procedural -- although given it's on FOX I'd say Sleepy Hollow would be an even closer match. I'm hopeful that the direction in S2 is a response to what viewers want, or perhaps what the writers originally wanted, rather the way that Community veered off into something quite different by S2. Sleepy Hollow had a lot of potential and some great people in the cast but was an utter mess of a show -- a former SPN showrunner was heading it, which told me nothing good was likely to occur.

Good to know what the hell setup was in the comics -- that makes more sense to me.

Date: 2017-02-09 01:00 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] chasingdemons.livejournal.com
Wow! You are really into the show, aren't you? I love it! Is there a fandom out there? Do you communicate with other fans? Will there be fanfic? What fun. I'm still waiting to be energized by another show. (Might be helpful if I actually watched one.) I did try to watch an episode of Lucifer. Primarily because I trust your judgment. But it just didn't grab me. I suppose I didn't give it a real chance.

Date: 2017-02-09 03:14 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] snogged.livejournal.com
I absolutely enjoy watching Lucifer, though you have me beat on the fandom level. (I know, I know. Not a contest. :P)
I wish we didn't have to wait until May.

Date: 2017-02-09 04:03 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rebcake.livejournal.com
hell seemed to be carrying on quite happily without Lucifer's presence

Indeed it did. And he can even get sucked in by its workings, which surprised me. I thought he'd be immune. Maybe his vulnerability extends into the beyond, when his body is in proximity to Chloe? My work around for his earlier statement about how hell has gone to hell, is that maybe he doesn't know as much as he thinks he does about all the mysterious ways of things. Which is a safe guess for somebody as thoroughly confident as he seems to be.

I like most of the characters, although I have problems with Chloe and Dan. In Chloe's case, this is terribly sad, as I want to LOVE the female lead, always. But she was so impatient and humorless for so long, that I got impatient with her. I'm warming up to her now, I think. The actor who plays Dan also played an unpleasant character on Ugly Betty back when. I kept wondering, "why do I not like this guy?" but then realized it was this association. Probably. He's also the kind of jock-y, morally unstable guy I'm not a huge fan of, character-wise. Angel, anyone? If a character is morally, um, fluid, I prefer they not be built like a linebacker into the bargain. Lucifer and Maze (and Mom) can be as slippery as they like and I'm completely entertained. But big cops going around shooting people and feeding them to the mob? Not as funny.

I'm happy to see D.B. Woodside every week, and Tricia Helfer, too. She is better at comedy than I knew. Go, Tricia! Dr. Linda is my absolute favorite, though, for reasons that are probably obvious to you. ;-) I hadn't actually considered that sex with a demon was part of Amenadiel's problem. I though it was that he got people killed. Silly me, not confusing sex with badness, again. Will I ever get this pop culture stuff right?

I still haven't read ANY of the comics. (But I did read the newest "Rivers of London" novel, finally! Woo hoo! I hooked a bunch of other people on those, once I got back to the states, and everybody is all caught up and panting for the next one, already. I did notice quite a few proofreading errors, though, which makes me cross.)

So much TV, so little time! I've been traveling a bunch, so I'm even more behind than usual.

Date: 2017-02-10 01:09 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] chasingdemons.livejournal.com
I couldn't agree more about Supernatural. I have tried to watch it many many times.

Is the WIP on your hard drive the Spangle fic you've talked about? I hope you are able to finish it too.

I'm extremely happy to hear about K's baby. Not that I've experienced it, but it just seems like being a grandmother is the best thing in the world.

Date: 2017-02-12 12:26 pm (UTC)
tinny: Lucifer with a red horned shadow "What's not to like?" (lucifer_whats not to like)
From: [personal profile] tinny
I thought he'd be immune. Maybe his vulnerability extends into the beyond, when his body is in proximity to Chloe?

Oh, that is a very good point! That hadn't occurred to me (probably because I was too busy enjoying Lucifer's punishment... ahem).

Date: 2017-02-12 12:39 pm (UTC)
tinny: Something Else holding up its colorful drawing - "be different" (Default)
From: [personal profile] tinny
'Aww, how terribly Jossian,' and instantly forgave them.

LOL, so cute. I definitely agree that their idea of hell has not been very fleshed out until only the latest episodes, so it never seemed very consistent to me.

In the first season they were all harping on about Lucifer deserting his post, and Amenadiel (of all people, lol) having to take over his job, which now makes no sense anymore. The way hell seems to work now doesn't require anyone's presence at all - not even the demons'.

All seven of the main characters (Lucifer, Chloe, Amenadiel, Maze, Dan, Dr Linda, Trixie) are fully formed and fleshed out from the very first episode.

True, and that worked in the show's favor from the beginning.

Although I still think Chloe somehow got the short end when it comes to characterization. In the first season, there isn't much beyond "love for Trixie" and "good, law-abiding cop". She always looked a bit bland next to Lucifer, and all the emotional episode beats were about him. But I think they did better with Chloe this season (and the s1 finale was pretty good, too). So maybe they have noticed that she needs more umph.

ripping off Supernatural

What exactly are you thinking of here? I'm not a huge Supernatural fan, but I have seen lots of eps (seasons 2 thru 6, and 8 thru 10).

They didn't have pregnancies (it's kinda hard if there are no actual female characters and the ones there are get killed off after at most five episodes).

They did have that one storyline where Sam falls for a demon and she makes him drink her blood to turn him evil (or something). Not sure if that was what you meant.

I can't really think of an instance where a celestial being was corrupted.

Unless you're thinking of Castiel trying to become God, but that doesn't really bear many similarities (except maybe Mom is trying to depose her ex :)) .

Or maybe you're referring to Castiel losing his wings? That happened to all the angels, so it's not something that applied specifically to him.

Anyway, if you have SPN questions, I can try hashing them out with you.

Date: 2017-02-12 08:51 pm (UTC)
tinny: Lucifer with a red horned shadow "What's not to like?" (lucifer_whats not to like)
From: [personal profile] tinny
all the celestial characters are. But that egotism seems in-character to me

Yes, I agree. I don't think you can measure them by human standards (although the show sometimes makes the mistake of assuming they would want the same things humans want). But overall, I like their characterization.

God and God's sister

Ah, that's season 11 and/or 12, and I haven't watched that (and also don't intend to).

I hope the story in Lucifer will be different.

Never, ever, ever trust Supernatural to handle female characters decently. It's the most misogynistic show.

In that respect, Lucifer has never tread wrong. Chloe always gives as good as she gets, never takes any of Lucifer's shit, and all the female characters are treated with respect. So I trust them to get Mom's storyline right, too.

Date: 2017-02-14 08:22 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rebcake.livejournal.com
Oh! And Ella! She's up there in my favorite character list. I happen to like characters that are enjoying themselves. Guilty, your honor.

Date: 2017-02-14 08:28 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rebcake.livejournal.com
Never, ever, ever trust Supernatural to handle female characters decently. It's the most misogynistic show.

Yes, I have heard this. I'm constantly surprised that it seems to have so many female fans.


The thing about Supernatural is that the main characters are NOT misogynistic and the female characters are really well done. The writers just insist on killing them all the time to make the main characters suffer more. *yawn* I haven't watched it in awhile, but the musical episode perfectly captured this with the song "A Single Man Tear". (BTW, the girls putting on the production actually survived the experience. Heh.)

Date: 2017-02-20 08:45 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] http://users.livejournal.com/_androgynous_/
how to fill the gulf of time until it returns
I signed up for this gift exchange (https://lucifer-gift-exchange.tumblr.com/) and I found a potential group chat (http://thefangirlconvention.tumblr.com/post/156952936677/a-little-thought-i-had). I should probably re-watch too instead of just perusing episode transcripts.

John Constantine
I really want to see John Constantine have a cameo on Lucifer (tv show). There's Ritchie Simpson as a paparazzo in 1x02 and Chas Chandler as a Russian mob boss in 2x07.
Lucifer purposely cuts himself multiple times in 2x12. John does something similar in the film Constantine.

having sex with a demon
Sounds like Hisui and Kokuyo from the manga Wish. Wish is a fluffy story so it's no big deal for the Angel Master of Wind and the son of Satan not being able to go back to heaven or hell because of what they did.
The main characters of this manga are an angel and a human so romance eventually happens...

Date: 2017-02-21 06:55 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] http://users.livejournal.com/_androgynous_/
These are characters out of the Hellblazer comic, are they?
You're correct. Ritchie and Chas were both featured in the tv version which had the same name as the movie. My biggest complaint about the Constantine tv show is that the ending felt lacking.

I have noticed that Lucifer and Mom have different attitudes regarding money. Lucifer bribes a police officer in the pilot episode. In 2x03, Mom says "I-I choose money. Does anyone choose life?" to her would-be mugger.

Profile

shapinglight: (Default)
None

March 2020

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 8th, 2026 06:06 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios